I look at the QB situation like this:
Thompson - It is very difficult to beat out a returning two year starter. The experience he has gained from the last two years is extremely valuable and it is his spot to lose. I attended several practices during the three week spring practice and the spring game. Derek had a great 3 weeks in practice and a marginal spring game. As the returning starter, and with the great 3 weeks of practice, the starting job was his to have but the performance in spring game left the door open for the fall.
Win or Lose? No Change
Bergland - Everybody had really high hopes on Brock coming into UNT and turning the program around single handedly. Many felt he would win the starting job right away. All of this was based on his evaluations as a high school QB from 2010. Not all highly recruited QB's have the skills needed at the next level. High School and D1 college football are two different games. An injury set Brock back this spring so we will not know if he has the skills to play D1 or not until the fall camp.
Win or Lose? Lose. Partly because of injury.
McNulty - Andrew was the clear winner of Spring Ball. He had a great 3 weeks of practice, AND he had a great spring game. Most people counted him out based on what he did as a true freshman in 2011. As a true freshman he competed for the starting job. His second year he red-shirted, and has now matured and is ready to fight for the strating job again. He showed a lot in the practices and clearly out performed Derek and Brock in the spring game. In the first half he moved the white team pretty well and he did a great job in the 4th quarter with the green team.
Win or Lose? Win. Don't count McNulty out of the race.