Great points of view by all of you. But as the Father of a current recruit who is "only" a 2 star and one who is going through the recruiting process let me say that to the majority of College Coaches star ratings meen very little in the final equasion. My son Abdul has been recruited by many P5 schools since his sophomore year and he continues to be contacted via mail and twitter constantly. Notre Dame, Missouri, Baylor, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Arkansas, BYU, California, Auburn, Alabama etc have all contacted him and have him on their recruiting boards. What I have discovered in this recruiting process is that the star system is not an exact process (tens of 1000's of kids are evaluated by staffs of less than 10-15 people esp for Rivals, 247, Scout and ESPN) and it is almost impossible to truly evaluate a kid based on HUDL. Film can be maniipulated (show highlights against your weakest, smallest opponents) and in addition all level of competition is NOT the same. In person evaulation, elite invite only camps (Under Armour Camp Series, Nike Football Training Camp, US Army All American Combine, The Opening etc) all along with game film evaulation helps to form an "opinion" on a star rating. In addition let me also state that in many cases the Star rating is an opinion on the "potential" of an athlete. Abdul was invited an attended for example the invite only Rivals Under Armour Camp Series Houston. Many players you may or may not know were at this camp (Tyler Moore, Josh Jones, Eric McCoy, Du'vonta Lampkin, Cody Ford,Cordell Iwuagwu,Toby Weathersby,Ed Oliver, Kingsley Keke, Joshua Uluocha etc) Many of these guys are 4 star recruits and have committed to P5 schools....yet Abdul when matched up 1 on 1 man to man dominated against them. Kingsley Keke is committed to Texas A&M, Ed Oliver is class of 2016 a top 300 player in the nation Abdul went 1 on 1 with both and dominated. In the end Abdul was named in the top 10 performers on offense any position for this elite camp. In closing I'm not saying Star rating doesn't mean anything or carry any weight but it does not determine if a school will suceed or not. Cyril Lemon was a 2 star player (supposedly) and look at what he has done in 3 years (Only player in the Nation to start everygame, All Conference player every year, Lombardi award watch list this year, Pre-Season All America this year, likely NFL draft pick) I think the fact that someone does not have a star rating or a low one is no indication of current or future ability. I had to "harass" Rivals, Scout, 247 sports to create Abdul's profile , give him an accurate rating and then update it as things occured....it's still not right. Abdul was 2nd team All State (TSWA) last season with no star rating and Pre-Season DCTF 6A All State this year as a 2 star. The coaching, the offensive and defensive systems and most of all the player himself determine how good or bad a class will be not the star ratings. Just my 2 cents.